Full Cast List ▾
Tom Everett Scott
Joe Matthews / Micah Matthias
Sarah Lancaster
Rachel Troyler
Thomas Kapanowski
Bobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias
Kelly McGillis
Bertha Troyler
Nicole Badaan
Kim
Annie Kitral
Lydia Troyler
🎬
Katherine DeBoer
Chloe Styles
🎬
Marianna Alacchi
Anna Troyler
Ken Strunk
Eli Troyler
Greg Violand
Ed Spencer
🎬
John Eby
Sam Phillips
🎬
Geoffrey Hoffman
Dylan Matthias
🎬
Kaitlyn Sapp
Elise
Chris Van Vliet
Reporter #1
🎬
Jeannie Madison
Reporter #2
🎬
Madison Blake
Ypung Rachel Troyler
🎬
Dave McConnell
Frank Troyer
Joe Kurak
Head Official
🎬
Dave Durch
Disheveled Guy
🎬
Kyle Primous
Mechanic
Serena Miller
Cashier
🎬
Kris Leiter
Umpire
Mary Anne Prevost
Mary Anne (Bank Teller)
🎬
Trenton Huff
Bobby Double
🎬
Abe M. Yoder
Horse & Buggy Wrangler
🎬
Nicole Miller
Horse Trainer
🎬
Blaze
Buggy Horse
🎬
Curtis Blackburn
Amish Youths Chasing Buggy
🎬
Jason Burroughs
Amish Youths Chasing Buggy
🎬
Ryan Schultz
Grungy Guy
🎬
Kirk Putman
Garaway Baseball Team
🎬
Michah VanFossen
Garaway Baseball Team
Brandon Weaver
Garaway Baseball Team
🎬
B.J. Schwartz
Garaway Baseball Team
🎬
Benjamin Mason
Garaway Baseball Team
🎬
Brandon Johnson
Garaway Baseball Team
